| The SF, Horror and Fantasy Film Review |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
| Science-Fiction |
|
|
| Horror |
|
|
| Fantasy |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
THE BLACK CAT
aka
THE HOUSE OF DOOM; THE VANISHING BODY
Rating:  ½
USA. 1934.
Director – Edgar G. Ulmer, Screenplay – Peter Ruric, Story – Peter Ruric & Edgar G. Ulmer, Suggested by the Short Story by Edgar Allan Poe, Photography (b&w) – John J. Mescall, Music Director – Heinz Roemheld, Art Direction – Charles D. Hall. Production Company – Universal.
Cast:
Bela Lugosi (Dr Vitus Werdegast), Boris Karloff (Hjalmar Poelzig), David Manners (Peter Alison), Jacqueline Wells (Joan Alison), Lucille Lund (Karen Poelzig), Egon Brecker (The Majordomo), Harry Cording (Thamal)
Plot: On a train journey through Hungary, American writer Peter Alison and his wife Joan share a carriage with psychologist Dr Vitus Werdegast. Werdegast offers them a ride at the station. But his car breaks down and so they seek refuge with Werdegast’s old friend Hjalmar Poelzig in the ultra-modern house Poelzig has built over the site of a WWI battlefield massacre. But once there they find that Werdegast has come seeking revenge against Poelzig, who commanded the station that was situated on the battlefield and took away Werdegast’s daughter and wife. As Poelzig and Werdegast engage in a battle of minds, they discover that Poelzig not only has Werdegast’s late wife’s dead body preserved in the house but has also married Werdegast’s daughter. Poelzig and Werdegast now engage in a chessgame for the soul of Joan, whom Poelzig wants to sacrifice in a Satanic ceremony.
The Black Cat is regarded as a classic of the horror genre. It was one of a mini-spate of Edgar Allan Poe-based films that came out during the 1930s featuring Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff – Lugosi had earlier appeared in Murders in the Rue Morgue (1932) and Lugosi and Karloff would later pair up again for The Raven (1935). Although the odd thing that you notice about The Black Cat is that it has nothing whatsoever to do with the Edgar Allan Poe’s 1843 story, which was about a man murdering his wife but giving himself away by accidentally bricking her cat up along with her body. The credits do note that the film was merely “suggested by the Edgar Allan Poe story”, although the connection is slim to the point of non-existence. Although to be fair Bela Lugosi’s character does at least manifest a pathological fear of cats and there is a black cat that turns up about five times throughout.
The film’s director, Hungarian-born Edgar G. Ulmer, had begun in silent German cinema, emigrated to the USA and worked steadily for the B studios throughout the 1930s, 40s and 50s. In the 1960s Ulmer was suddenly rediscovered and championed as an auteur by French critics where The Black Cat and his film noir thriller Detour (1944) were held up as the two chief exhibits. Edgar G. Ulmer’s appeal one feels was overrated as the majority of his output was mostly hackwork like The Man from Planet X (1951), Babes in Bagdad (1952), Daughter of Dr Jekyll (1957), The Amazing Transparent Man (1960), Beyond the Time Barrier (1960) and The Lost Kingdom/Journey Beneath the Desert (1961). Certainly The Black Cat is the best of Edgar G. Ulmer’s films, even if it is not really a great one.
The film’s plot, which manages to pack in twisted revenge schemes, war crimes, Satanism and human sacrifice, necrophile obsession, the slightly distasteful concept of Boris Karloff marrying both his enemy’s wife and daughter, chess games for human souls and an ending where Bela Lugosi plans to flay Karloff alive, certainly makes it quite a curiosity piece. The film gains a substantial frisson from the pairing of Lugosi and Karloff (the first of eight such screen pairings). In a reversal of what would later become typecasting for either actor, Lugosi plays the hero and Karloff the villain, and the reversal of expectation adds quite an element of tension. With Karloff skulking about in Mephistophelean haircut, dressing gown and looking his most gaunt and hollow, and Lugosi perpetually overdramatizing every syllable, the film seems charged every time the two appear on the screen.
Where The Black Cat does fall down is in that most of its depravities are all only suggested and take place off-screen. The most we ever see is Boris Karloff tied up and stripped to the waist getting ready to be flayed and the Satanists turning up in robes for the ceremony. It is a surprisingly talky film – in fact it would be quite easy to resurrect this as a stage play. Furthermore, where one feels his reputation is overrated, Edgar G. Ulmer directs in a rather workmanlike manner. The look of the film is akin to a serial where directors would direct everything in master shots because closeups involved more camera set-ups thus took longer to shoot. Ulmer rarely ever moves in to break scenes up – the chess game deciding the fate of Jacqueline Wells, for example, is notably lacking in suspense and takes place in a single wide angle shot. Another director might have drawn the tension out unbearably – it’s certainly what the scene almost sits up and demands. Ulmer uses some interestingly modernist sets influnced by the German bauhaus movement rather than the Gothic setting that was de rigeur for the day, but again fails to make any use of these in a visual way.
Edgar G. Ulmer’s other films of genre interest are:– Bluebeard (1944); Strange Illusion (1945) about a man’s precognitive dream; the alien invader film The Man from Planet X (1951); Daughter of Dr Jekyll (1957); the invisible man film The Amazing Transparent Man (1960); Beyond the Time Barrier (1960), a variant on the astronaut ending up in a mutant-ruled future; and The Lost Kingdom/Journey Beneath the Desert (1961), a cheap remake of the oft-filmed L’Atlantide.
Other versions of Edgar Allan Poe’s The Black Cat are:– The Black Cat (1941), The Black Cat (1966), Lucio Fulci’s The Black Cat (1981) and Luigi Cozzi’s The Black Cat (1990). The story is also adapted in the Poe anthologies Tales of Terror (1962) and Two Evil Eyes (1990).
Copyright Richard Scheib 2000
|