The SF, Horror and Fantasy Film Review
General Indexes
All Titles
· A – B · C – D
· E – F · G – H
· I – K · L – M
· N – O · P – R
· S – T · U – Z
Reviews
Science-Fiction
· A – D · E – K
· L – Q · R – Z
Horror
· A – D · E – K
· L – Q · R – Z
Fantasy
· A – D · E – K
· L – Q · R – Z
New
· Most Recent Additions
Best & Worst
· 2007 · 2002
· 2006 · 2001
· 2005 · 2000
· 2004 · 1999
· 2003 · 1998


THE BEST AND WORST OF 2004

The author’s considered best/worst in each category are listed in bold italics with an asterisk (*). The listed links will take you to more detailed reveiews of each film.



Recurrent Themes of the Year:
Marvel Comics AdaptationsBlade Trinity, The Punisher and Spider-Man 2
Films About the Editing of MemoryEternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, The Final Cut, The Forgotten and The Manchurian Candidate
George Romero Zombie HomagesDawn of the Dead and Shaun of the Dead
Loved Ones are RebornBirth and Godsend
Fantasy Worlds Overrun by References to Contemporary Brand NamesElla Enchanted, Shark Tale and Shrek 2
Modernized Teen Versions of CinderellaA Cinderella Story and Ella Enchanted
Critiques of US PoliticsThe Manchurian Candidate, Team America: World Police and a whole host of non-genre documentaries about Bush
Revivals/Homages to 1970s Horror FilmsExorcist: The Beginning and the aforementioned Romero films
Retro SFThe Incredibles, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow and Steamboy
Puppet FilmsStrings, Team America: World Police and, if you like, Thunderbirds

The 10 Best Films
  1. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
  2. Saw
  3. Strings
  4. Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow
  5. Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence
  6. Team America: World Police
  7. D.E.B.S.
  8. 2046
  9. The Ordeal
  10. Howl’s Moving Castle


Worst Films
  1. Van Helsing
  2. Riding the Bullet
  3. Boa vs Python
  4. Ella Enchanted
  5. Catwoman



Best Director
Jonathan Glazer – Birth
Joseph Ruben – The Forgotten
M. Night Shyamalan – The Village
Christopher Smith – Creep
James Wan – Saw (*)
Zhang Yimou – House of Flying Daggers



Best Original Screenplay
The Butterfly Effect
D.E.B.S.
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (*)
The Final Cut
Saw



Best Adapted Screenplay
Appleseed
Howl’s Moving Castle (*)
The Manchurian Candidate
Night Watch
Spider-Man 2



Best Actor
Christian Bale – The Machinist (*)
C. Thomas Howell – The Hillside Strangler
Tong Leung Chiu Wai – 2046
Sean Penn – The Assassination of Richard Nixon
Ron Perlman – Hellboy



Best Actress
Jordana Brewster– D.E.B.S.
Sara Foster – D.E.B.S.
Bryce Dallas Howard – The Village (*)
Bai Ling – Dumplings
Emmy Rossum – The Phantom of the Opera
Zhang Ziyi – House of Flying Daggers and 2046



Best Supporting Actor
Jackie Berroyer – The Ordeal
Cameron Bright – Birth
Liev Schreiber – The Manchurian Candidate
John Turturro – Secret Window (*)
Nicholas Turturro – The Hillside Strangler



Best Supporting Actress
Minnie Driver – The Phantom of the Opera
Kirsten Dunst – Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (*)
Trine Dyrholm – In Your Hands
Anne Heche – Birth
Parker Posey – Blade Trinity



Best Cinematography
Ab-Normal Beauty
Birth
House of Flying Daggers (*)
The Phantom of the Opera
Romasanta: The Werewolf Hunt



Best Musical Score
Birth (*)
Secret Window
Taking Lives
Team America: World Police
The Village



Best Special Effects
The Day After Tomorrow (*)
I, Robot
Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow
Spider-Man 2
Van Helsing



Best Makeup Effects
Alien vs. Predator
Blade Trinity
Creep
Dawn of the Dead
Hellboy (*)
Seed of Chucky



Best Production Design
Casshern
The Chronicles of Riddick
Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events
The Phantom of the Opera
Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow (*)
Thunderbirds